However, sometimes he can be a little immature, such as in "Toby's Untrue Achoo!" when he faked being sick in order to get some attention. In "Toby the Cowsitter", he offers to watch a group of cows and then leaves to get milkshakes, suggesting he's also forgetful.
He's also very innocent, rarely ever understanding the times he's being swindled or even insulted, such as in "Peck Takes it Back", where Peck calls him a pinecone. Instead, Toby goes out to find an actual pinecone for Peck because he believes he didn't know what they looked like. He doesn't seem to hold grudges or get angry easily, either, even after his skills are criticized in "Horseshoe Peck". In "Toby Braves the Bully" he is against telling Callie and Peck about his bully because he thinks it would make him a tattletale.
Toby is usually very cheerful and he loves to dance. He is also shown to love popcorn in several episodes, as well as milkshakes.
Main:Sheriff Callie • Deputy Peck • Toby • Sparky Others:Clementine • Doc Quackers • Priscilla Skunk • Frida Fox • Uncle Bun • Mr. Dillo • Ella Cowbelle • Tio Tortuga • Farmer Stinky • Dirty Dan and Dusty • Mama Bun • Pecos Pug • Dosie Doe • Rita Rattler • Baxter Badger • Abigail Crane • Cody • Mr. Engineer • Dr. Wolf • Parroting Pedro • Polly May Porcupine • Ray Jay and Jay Jay • Twirler Kid • Gerty and Grimy Grace • Prairie Dog Trio Bandits and Outlaws:Tricky Travis • Oswald • Train Bandits • The Milk Bandit • Trouble Brothers • Teddy Trouble • Animal Rustlers • Jethro Beaver • Jolene Beaver • Phineas Foolery • Billy Goat the Kid • Kit Cactus • Mean McGee • Barney the Barnstorming Bandit • Silverado Brothers • Johnny Strum • Wildcat McGraw • Dingus and Durwood Fink • Ma Fink
Songs
Sheriff Callie's Wild West Theme Song • Horseshoe Peck is the Best • Count on Us • Chugga Chugga Choo Choo Train • Sayin' I'm Sorry • Picture Perfect • Apology Song • Amazing Lucky Scarf • There's a Scary-Looking Wolf in Town • Milkshake Shake • Ask for Help • If You Could Go Fast • Wish I Could Do Tricks Like That • I Wish I'd Never Lied • The Spotlight • Those Peppers • Vanilla Plains • The Fabulous Fantastic Flying Mule • May the Best Brother Win • Ridin' • Just a Little T.L.C. • I'm Gonna Get to the Bottom of This • Cattle Drive • Sparky Come Back to Me • Super Shiny Deputy Star • Dancin' the Cowgirl Twirl • The Pie Thief • Big City • How Hard Can it Be to Knit? • That's How a Gentleman Does It • We're Gonna Get Along Just Fine • Gonna Find My Story • Hot Hot Heat • Gotta Pick 'em Fast • My Mustache and Me • The Whole Town's Cookin' • Who Could it Be? • I Found a Prickly Pal • I'm Not A-Scared of Nothin' • You're Not a Tattletale • We're Gonna Clean Up Our Town • Rustle Up That Rhyme • Ballad of El Yo-Yo • The Bandit Life • Founders Day Hoedown • Brother's Gone Clean • You'll Be Surprised • I Can Do Anything • Fixin' to Surprise 'em • Rodeo Clown • A Critter I Can Ride • The Christmas March • We'll Have a Nice and Friendly Christmas • Blame it on Toby • I Gotta Do Somethin' • Wait Till You See This Trick • Doc Knows it All • Play All Day • Shake, Stir, & Serve with Pizzazz • Snow Day • Get Up and Try Again • Please Don't Leave Me • Our New Fire Engine • Wagons Ho • Now That I'm Tall • It's My Turn Now • Gotta Get a Buckle • She Won't Stop • Strut Our Stuff • The Ballad of Sweet Strings • Popcorn and Glory • We Run This Town • My Wish for You • You Can Do It • My Friend and I • Why We Love Halloween • The Ghost of the Scary Prairie • There's a Present for Me • I'm Gonna Get Me Some Milk • There's Always Room for More • The Fastest Flipper • Everybody's Got Some Good in Them • I'm Gonna Be Big News • There's a New Sheriff in Town • Nobody Flies Like Me • Getting Valentines • That Gold is Mine
